Hello
again, dear reader.
In
early issue of the conversations we have been talking about being a "Badass"
and there is nothing more tough guy or "Badass" then being able to
improvise a solution for any number of situations that may arise. And every
time I think about improvisation. I tend to think about when pop culture icon
that has become the epitome of the word improvisation, and then his MacGyver
MacGyver could improvise anything he could defuse a nuclear reactor with a
chocolate bar he was so good. As a matter of fact that, is anime has become
part of the American lexicon for a person's ability to adapt and improve it to
"MacGyver. Something needs to succeed where others have failed, against
all odds. So hopefully by the end of today's conversation, dear reader, you
will have a better understanding of what it means to improvise, adapt and overcome...
MacGyver
is stuck in the attic of a house. Bad guys are coming up the stairs and about
to bust into the room. The only way out is through a window, but it’s a ways
up, and angry Doberman Pinschers wait below. MacGyver searches through the
attic and grabs a bottle of cleaning fluid, mothballs, a telescope, a pulley, a
rope, and a metal rod. He hastily assembles a rocket-propelled harpoon from the
seemingly random materials, which he then uses to create a zip line to a tree
outside. Just as the bad guys breach the room, he glides away to safety.
Awesome,
right? This was just one of the many improvised gadgets and explosives MacGyver
created during the 7-year run of the television series that bore his name. The
show was so successful and memorable, that despite being canceled in 1992, it
remains one of the most recognizable touchstones of popular culture and has
even entered our lexicon; to jury-rig something using only the materials you
have on hand is to “MacGyver” it.
The
“MacGruber” SNL parody, which improbably became a full-length film, has lent
MacGyver a cheesier and more satirical air in recent times, but there’s still
something about the character that strongly resonates. And that resonance
actually goes a lot deeper than pop culture; it in fact points to an universal
archetype of manliness, and a trait of masculinity that has been valued and
celebrated across times and cultures: improvisation.
A Case Study in Masculine
Improvisation: The Cretan Glendiots
To
understand how and why the ability to improvise has, and continues to be,
considered a particularly compelling and manly trait, let us travel to the
island of Crete off the coast of Greece. It was here in the 1970s that
anthropologist Michael Herzfeld studied the culture of masculinity in a small
mountainous village he dubbed “Glendi” (the name was a pseudonym, to protect
the confidentiality of its residents). The Glendiots were a pastoral people,
and because of the remoteness and hardscrabble nature of their village, had
retained much of the traditional code of manhood that marked cultures
around the world for thousands of years. The men had a reputation as strong,
independent, outlaw-types, and stealing sheep from neighboring villages’ flocks
was a central part of demonstrating their manhood; the practice was not
considered by them to be immoral, but rather a way to build alliances (there’s
a lot to unpack on this subject, and as the culture of shepherds as a whole,
especially contrasted with that of farmers, is such a fascinating topic, we’ll
cover it in full down the line).
It
is in fact a Glendiot idiom that gave to us the distinction between being a
“good man” and “being good at being a man.” And part of
earning the latter distinction was mastering the art of improvisation. Women
assuredly improvised too, but more often practiced this skill within the
privacy of the household. Men were expected to demonstrate their adeptness in
the public arena, so that others could judge their prowess. Such
demonstrations were made through sheep raiding, dancing and singing contests,
drinking and toasting, telling jokes, showing hospitality to guests, and
playing cards. In such things, Herzfeld writes in The
Poetics of Manhood, it wasn’t enough simply to do the minimum
and stick with the basics; to show you were good at being a man, you had to
invest your actions with “flair and distinctiveness” and achieve:
“performative
excellence,
the ability to foreground manhood by deeds that strikingly ‘speak for
themselves.’ Actions that occur at a conventional pace are not noticeable;
everyone works hard, most adult males dance elegantly enough, any shepherd can
steal a sheep on some occasion or other. What counts…is a sense of shifting the
ordinary and everyday context where the very change of context itself serves to
invest it with sudden significance. Thus, instead of showing what men
do, Glendiots focus their attention on how the act is performed.”
As
is the dynamic of all male groups, Glendiot men both competed as individuals to
achieve status within their village, and banded together to compete for status
with other villages. Demonstrating one’s ability to improvise was one of the
surest routes to achieving high standing as individuals and as a group. Honored
was the man who didn’t seem as if he had planned out every move of a successful
action ahead of time, and appeared to “have ‘chanced’ (etikhene) upon
the flock he raids, the verse he suddenly thought up, the food he is able to
serve his unexpected guests.” To the Glendiots, Herzfeld observes, “flexibility
and an ability to make the best of any situation are key components in the
definition of the true man.”
Why
would this be so? Why would the ability to improvise be considered such a
valuable and honored trait amongst the Glendiots, and other cultures as well?
There are several reasons.
Why Improvisation Is a Valuable and
Manly Trait
Offers an advantage in battles, of all
kinds.
“The
qualities that make a good soldier are, in large part, the qualities that
make a good hunter. Most important of all is the ability to shift for one’s
self, the mixture of hardihood and resourcefulness which enables a man to tramp
all day in the right direction, and, when night comes, to make the best of
whatever opportunities for shelter and warmth may be at hand. Skill in the use
of the rifle is another trait; quickness in seeing game, another; ability to
take advantage of cover, yet another; while patience, endurance, keenness of
observation, resolution, good nerves, and instant readiness in an emergency,
are all indispensable.” –Theodore Roosevelt, Outdoor Pastimes of the
American Hunter
In
every kind of competition, the man who can improvise has an edge. You can train
all you want, and make the most thorough of plans, but you can never predict
with certainty all the moves your opponent will make (including the wrenches
thrown by Mother Nature). As the military maxim goes: “No plan survives contact
with the enemy.” Or as Mike Tyson memorably said: “Everyone’s got a plan ‘til
they get punched in the mouth.”
The
ability to adapt to changing circumstances is key in winning any battle,
including those of the non-physical variety. For example, the Glendiots had
singing contests where men traded improvised verses back and forth. Those who
crafted a clever new idiom, or used a familiar one in a fresh context, garnered
the respect of their fellow villagers. Predictability was considered a flaw, and
it was an insult to imply that one’s opponent was a hack who didn’t have the
cojones and ingenuity to play with convention and create something original,
clever, and effective.
The
same dynamic exists in everything from debating contests to rap battles to musical
“duels.” Jazz has always been considered a distinctly masculine genre of music
because of its emphasis on competition and improvisation; piano players in
1920s New York, for example, would often muster for rousing back-and-forth
“battles,” with each man trotting out his best stuff in late-night cutting
sessions. To come out on top, you had to have a readiness with the notes, and
an ability to riff on whatever was happening.
The
competitive nature of contests of all kinds brings up another manly virtue of
improvisation: embracing risk. To improvise takes courage — you have to step in
the arena and hope that whatever you need will come to you in the moment,
accepting that, if it doesn’t, you will royally fail.
Enhances the ability to adapt to
challenging circumstances and uncertainty.
It
is not so surprising that the Glendiots, who lived a rugged, hardscrabble life,
would “applaud in word and deed: the serendipitous response to hardship and
poverty, the ability to turn the meager gifts of chance to advantage.” The man
who can make the most of whatever he’s got is going to be better able to
fulfill his central roles as a man, and be the superior protector and provider. We respect the guerilla warrior who is able
to take on forces that have much more equipment, weapons, and money — who is
able to create inventive ways to trap and weaken a far greater foe. We imbue
much more heroism into the David than the Goliath. Likewise, we have more
respect for the man who can catch a fish with an improvised
spear or dissemble a cell phone
and use it to survive in the wild, than one who’s got a backpack full of
high-tech gear.
The
reason we respect those with the ability to improvise weapons and gadgets is
that we know life is incredibly uncertain. We may be living in luxury now, but
might one day be struggling through a harsh environment. In such a situation,
the resourceful man — the man who is able to “make the most of whatever chance
offers” — is the man we want on our team, and that we hope to be ourselves.
He’s the guy who will get us through.
The
ability to improvise speaks not only to a tangible skill for jury-rigging, but
also to a tough, flexible, resilient mindset. A man who has confidence that he
can find a way out of a challenging circumstance, even when prospects are grim,
is someone far less likely to break down in the heat of crisis.
So
too, improvisation doesn’t just help in combat or survival situations. A man
who can find new ways to stretch a budget, repair something without buying
an expensive part or calling in a professional, figure out a way to defuse a
tense dispute between friends, think of a comforting word to say to a
distraught relative, or come up with an alternative date when the one he plans
go awry, carries a lot of value.
For
these reasons, Glendiot men actually welcome challenges, and “rejoice in the
very uncertainty of their lives, since it is this that gives them the chance to
demonstrate their improvisational skills.” And it’s true: there can be
something uniquely satisfying about making something out of seemingly nothing —
more so than if you had a ton of options and materials to work with. It feels
good to know you have a bit of the MacGyver in you — that come what may, you
are always prepared.
Sharpens the ability to seize an
unexpected opportunity.
Improvisation
isn’t only valuable as a defensive skill that allows you to effectively react
to challenging circumstances. Being resourceful and able to think on your feet
also allows you to be proactive in grasping positive opportunities. The
Glendiots believed that “the greatest achievements are those that entail
seizing some quite unexpected chance.”
Let’s
say your boss calls on you to make an impromptu presentation to an important
client. Could you ace it? Or a woman unexpectedly responds to your advances and
wants to go somewhere to hang out. Could you figure out what to do next?
When
Theodore Roosevelt was president, an autographed copy of the poem “Opportunity”
by John James Ingalls was said to be the only thing besides a portrait to hang
in his executive office in the White House. It sums up the importance of being
able to seize the chances that suddenly appear, and just as quickly disappear,
from our lives:
Master
of human destinies am I!
Fame, love, and fortune on my footsteps wait.
Cities and fields I walk; I penetrate
Deserts and seas remote, and passing by
Hovel and mart and palace—soon or late
I knock unbidden once at every gate!
Fame, love, and fortune on my footsteps wait.
Cities and fields I walk; I penetrate
Deserts and seas remote, and passing by
Hovel and mart and palace—soon or late
I knock unbidden once at every gate!
If
sleeping, wake—if feasting, rise before
I turn away. It is the hour of fate,
And they who follow me reach every state
Mortals desire, and conquer every foe
Save death; but those who doubt or hesitate
Condemned to failure, penury, and woe,
Seek me in vain, and uselessly implore.
I answer not, and I return no more!
I turn away. It is the hour of fate,
And they who follow me reach every state
Mortals desire, and conquer every foe
Save death; but those who doubt or hesitate
Condemned to failure, penury, and woe,
Seek me in vain, and uselessly implore.
I answer not, and I return no more!
Creates a tool that can quickly shut
down a naysayer and/or resolve conflict without violence.
Herzfeld
found that being able to offer a clever, improvised quip or insult had the
perhaps counterintuitive ability “to restrain physical violence.” This was
because responding to a verbal insult “with knife or fist would demean the
assailant by suggesting that he was incapable of responding with some witty
line of his own.” In other words, if you insult an opponent in a really clever
way, it limits his options as to how to retaliate. He could still sock you, but
lashing out physically shows he can’t reply with an equally witty retort, which
dishonors him in the eyes of his audience. He must remain silent, and take his
verbal licking.
Even
if violence is unlikely to occur in a dispute, a sharp, witty quip can quickly
shut down a heckler or critic, leaving him speechless. Winston Churchill, for
example, was a master of this art!
Thus,
being able to throw out a really clever put-down can sometimes end an argument
and vanquish a foe without it coming to blows. This makes improvisation an
especially valuable tool for the weaker, less formidable man, and indeed, men
who haven’t been blessed with physical prowess have often honed their humor and
wit into a potent weapon.
Tailored communication = greater
effectiveness.
Have
you ever gotten an email where you can tell the writer was just sending the
same template to multiple people, and simply changing a few details like your
name? Or have you attended concerts from the same artist in multiple cities,
and heard them give the exact same shoutouts and banter to the audience? In
these instances you probably felt like the sender/artist was less sincere, and
it weakened your affinity for them.
Humans
prefer communication that seems spontaneous — that’s tailored to the specific
circumstances of the time and the audience. Someone who uses the same speech,
pick-up lines, jokes, sales pitch, etc. in every situation, often finds that their
banter falls flat because it doesn’t best fit the exigencies of the moment. A
man who has the core elements of what he wants to say in mind, but then tailors
his message to the changing circumstances, is the far more effective
communicator.
Creates a memorable, impressive
reputation.
The
abilities gained by a man who masters improvisation don’t just pay off in the
effective actions he is able to perform, but the reputation those actions
create for him.
Classically,
honor meant having a reputation worthy of
admiration and respect. It was earned by winning kudos from one’s
fellow men. Achieving such a reputation is useful, because it makes other men
want to be your friend and ally, instead of having you as their enemy. And it
acts as a deterrent to attacks, as a man with a reputation for strength, skill,
and ingenuity is not someone others want to mess with.
In
Greek and Cretan culture, a man’s reputation, his whole identity, was staked on
the actions he took. As Herzfeld writes, “Insofar as he can foreground
the quality of his ‘doing,’ Glendiots are able to appreciate what he ‘is.’”
Doing deeds that demonstrated improvisation was an especially effective way to
build an honorable reputation, because such actions surprise, impress, and even
shock others, and are thus very memorable. Improvised action effectively served
notice to a man’s audience or opponent of the skill, ingenuity, and
quick-thinking he was capable of. As Herzfeld writes, in all competitive
domains, “a man’s every action must proclaim itself a further proof of his
manhood. An action that fails to point up its own excellence is like the
proverbial tree falling in an empty forest.”
The
Bread Helmet: Memorable masculine improvisation at its finest, if not its most
functional.
Impressing
an audience wasn’t just about pride, but turning an improvised escapade into a
story that one’s peers would tell and re-tell — one that would burnish his
reputation far and wide. “Remember that time when that dude made a
rocket-propelled harpoon out of a telescope and moth balls?” Once such a story
got around, competitors would think twice about challenging that man. Not to
mention, the ladies would be pretty intrigued (if not by the gadgetry, then
definitely by the mullet).
Think
about the famous quips of Winston Churchill that still get passed around today.
When Herzfeld shared some with the Glendiots, they were so impressed and tickled
by Churchill’s improvisational wit, they would make the anthropologist repeat
the stories over and over again.
Imbues life with meaning.
If
no one was around to witness your impressively improvised feat, you had to be
able to tell the story in a memorable way yourself — another skill that
involved the mastery of improvisation! In Glendi, men were judged not only on
the action, but how well they spun a narrative about it. In turn, the act
itself and the subsequent story folded back on each other, as Herzfeld
explains:
“If
the narratives reproduce the quality of raiding, moreover, it is also true that
the raids in turn possess some of the expressive properties of narrative.
Glendiot idiom recognizes this in the use of istoria, ‘tale,’ for any
exciting event, be it interpersonal violence or adventure in the foothills.
‘We’ll have ‘tales’’ means that serious quarrels are anticipated. But the term
is particularly apposite for animal raids…As the shepherd with whom I began
this chapter recalled: ‘I remember the first time I went on such a tale.’”
Glendiots
believed that an embrace of improvisation, the relishing of the chance to be
resourceful and take advantage of serendipity, made “an adventure out of every
encounter.” They also felt it added simasia or meaning to life.
Glendiots
regarded life “as a barren stretch of time, a blank page on which the genuine
poet of his own manhood must write as an engaging an account as he can.” The
more one is able to improvise things like humor, better ways to spend one’s time,
and how to pull off an exciting escapade, “the more successful the
transcendence of the mundane existence and the more pleasing aesthetically the
resulting memory.” For this reason, Glendiots believed that “The ability to
play with conventions in aesthetically intriguing ways, and above all to seize
opportunity from unpromising materials, is what generates simasia in
particular contexts.”
Part
of why improvisation creates meaning is that in bending “fickle chance to the
actor’s own ends and the comfort of his guests” he reveals “an infinite swath
of possibilities.” Improvisation takes words and materials out of their
ordinary context, and puts them into a new one; “I never would have thought an egg
could have been used to fix a radiator!” The audience of such an act
not only sees the improvised object in a new light, but it inspires them to
look at everything else from a different perspective as well; what other interesting
opportunities might be hiding in the seemingly mundane?
Another
part of the meaning improvisation imparts to life, is the way is puts a man in
the role of competitor with death itself. In Greek symbolism, Herzfeld
explains, “Death is a talented thief” who steals you away from mortality. This
is not just meant literally, as in final, physical death, but also in the slow,
everyday crushing of one’s spirit and joy. To fight back, to take the
unpromising, meager materials given to you by circumstance, and turn them into
something meaningful and successful that rises above the ordinary and adds
something to your life, and to the lives of others, is then in Glendiot idiom
to “seize a bad hour from death.”
Think
about the most memorable experiences of your life. Were they not often the
times where things went awry or the going was tough, but you managed to make
the most of it anyway? “Death” had conspired to rob you of having a good time
and a meaningful experience, and had you given in, he would have won. You would
have lost those hours or years forever. But through improvising a plan B, you
snatched them back from Death’s wilting touch.
“A
well-lived life,” the Glendiots thus say, “is a life of well-stolen moments,
each one unique.”